the players tried to take the field, but the marching band refused to yield

[coyotesuspect]

OH HAY. BACK FROM CAMP. HAD A BLAST. SLEPT LIKE FOUR OR FIVE HOURS A NIGHT.  AM EXHAUSTED.   HEARTBROKEN OVER WORLD CUP.  HAVE STARTED WATCHING AMERICAN MAJOR LEAGUE SOCCER. HAVE WRITTEN OVER 4000 WORDS SINCE COMING HOME.[Poll #1588493]

My argument: Remus/Sirius.

Both have awful childhoods. As a couple (if you accept that they're a couple), they're broken apart by distrust during a time in which all their friends are dying, spend most of their adult lives alone- one as a prisoner in Azkaban, the other poverty stricken and ostracized by society, only, after being briefly reunited, to both die relatively young. Sam/Dean, at least, still have the possibility of a happy ending, and, since they're the heroes of their text, are pretty likely to get that happy ending.

cherie_morte  's argument: Sam/Dean (as summarized by me! So possibly unfair/limited. Let me know if you want to add/rewrite anything bb)

Fucking your brother isn't a happy ending. At least Remus and Sirius end up in an afterworld that is posited as being pretty cool and happy. Sam and Dean's  lives are unremittingly bleak and tragic. Neither of them have a childhood, every time they have something good, it's ripped away from them. They're forced to watch the most important person in their life (each other) die or betray them again and again. Also? the S5 season finale.

ALSO. I HAVE JUST REALIZED, TONKS=LISA, TEDDY=BEN. SIRIUS WANTED REMUS TO HAVE A CHANCE AT HAPPINESS. *flail* *spazz*

 

Comments

[opheliahyde.livejournal.com]

I GO TO SLEEP EARLY AND MISS THIS AMAZING DEBATE. FAIL, HEATHER, FAIL.

I picked Remus/Sirius because THEY ARE SO SAD AND ONLY GOT TO BE HAPPY FOR A SORT OF AMOUNT OF TIME AND WERE SEPERATED, IN TOTAL, MUCH MORE TIME THAN SAMNDEAN HAVE BEEN SEPERATED IN THEIR LIVES (unless we're counting the forty years in Hell as forty years).

As for Azkaban vs. Hell, I'm not entirely sure they're so different? Dean was tortured in Hell, but so was Sirius, in his way, as he had to be around dementors, which made Harry pass out because of the memories they brought out and he had to be around them all the time and he grew up in that crazy house. THIS IS JUST MY CRAZY THEORY.

P.S. WELCOME BACK.

[familiardevil.livejournal.com]

YEAH BUT DEAN WAS IN HELL FOR FORTY YEARS
AND WAS STARTING TO BECOME A DEMON
HELL WAS MUCH WORSE THAN AZKABAN GIIIIRL

[opheliahyde.livejournal.com]

HAS CANON ACTUALLY SAID HE WAS BECOMING A DEMON? CUZ RUBY SAID THAT AND WE ALL KNOW RUBY IS A LYING LIAR WHO LIES.
DEMENTORS SUCK SOULS. WHAT IF BEING AROUND THEM ALL THE TIME MAKES LITTLE PIECES OF YOUR SOUL JUST... DISAPPEAR?

[familiardevil.livejournal.com]

EVEN IF THAT WERE THE CASE
FORTY YEARS IS STILL WORSE THAN LIKE, TEN OR WHATEVER

[opheliahyde.livejournal.com]

I AM JUST GOING TO STAND IN THIS CORNER OVER HERE AND POUT AT YOU WITH MY BIG, BLUE ANIME EYES. SO THERE.

[familiardevil.livejournal.com]

;)

[opheliahyde.livejournal.com]

:P

[lavendergaia]

I don't remember Azkaban making you TORTURE OTHER PEOPLE FOR SHITS AND GIGGLES. Or scream "SAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAM" in the most heartbreaking way ever that they should never use for Wayward Son montages because it HURTS.

[opheliahyde.livejournal.com]

YOU SHIP REMUS/SIRIUS PASSIVELY, THIS ISN'T FAIR. *stamps foot immaturely*

[lavendergaia]

[death-box.livejournal.com]

SO I'MA JUST HIDE OUT IN THIS REMUS/SIRIUS CORNER WITH YOU, OKAY?

(KELLY IF YOU'RE READING THIS, IGNORE MY ABOVE COMMENT. THE VICODIN TOTALLY MADE ME DO IT. MHM.)